Fremantle Dockers Offer Picks 10 and 18 for Shai Bolton – Should They Walk Away if Rejected?

In a bold move ahead of the upcoming AFL trade period, the Fremantle Dockers have tabled a significant offer for Richmond Tigers star Shai Bolton. Fremantle has reportedly put forward their prized picks 10 and 18 in the 2024 AFL Draft, a move that signals their intent to bolster their midfield and forward stocks with one of the competition’s most dynamic players.

The Dockers are eyeing Bolton, a dual premiership player and All-Australian, as the X-factor who could elevate their squad into genuine premiership contention. Known for his electrifying pace, elite skills, and game-breaking ability, Bolton would bring exactly the kind of spark Fremantle needs to complement their developing young list.

Shai Bolton is a rare talent, equally adept at impacting the game from the midfield or as a forward. His ability to win clearances, break the lines with blistering speed, and create scoring opportunities makes him a dangerous proposition for any opposition. Bolton also adds a layer of unpredictability and flair, qualities that have helped the Tigers remain a perennial finals contender.


For the Dockers, acquiring Bolton would instantly elevate their forward line and add depth to their midfield rotations, giving them the versatility and explosiveness that could transform them from finals hopefuls to premiership threats. After narrowly missing the top eight in recent years, the Dockers appear to be searching for that final piece to complete their puzzle.


Offering two first-round draft picks, including a top-10 selection, is no small gesture. Picks 10 and 18 represent significant draft capital and suggest Fremantle is willing to pay a steep price for Bolton’s services. In the eyes of many, this is a fair and reasonable offer that adequately reflects Bolton’s value as one of the premier players in the competition.


While Richmond might hesitate to part with a player of Bolton’s calibre, the offer of two early draft picks could be enticing for a club looking to transition into its next phase of development. The Tigers could use those picks to bring in fresh, young talent as they seek to rebuild their list after the departure of several senior players and a challenging 2024 campaign.


However, there is a question looming over this potential deal: what happens if Richmond says no? For Fremantle, walking away might be the most prudent option. While Bolton is undeniably a game-changer, paying more than two first-round picks could set the club back in the long term. Overpaying for one player, even one as talented as Bolton, risks compromising Fremantle’s future by forfeiting valuable draft assets that could help sustain their list for years to come.

Fremantle has shown restraint in recent trade periods, avoiding the kind of rash decision-making that can cripple a club’s list management strategy. Given the depth of talent available in the 2024 AFL Draft, the Dockers could do well to hold onto those picks and target emerging talent, rather than mortgaging their future for one player.

Bolton’s value is undeniable, but Fremantle must also consider the impact of losing two first-round picks and potentially more if Richmond counters with an even higher demand. If the Tigers refuse, walking away could be the right call, maintaining their list flexibility and avoiding a situation where the price becomes too steep.

**Conclusion: A Defining Moment for Fremantle**

This trade proposal represents a defining moment for Fremantle’s list management team. The offer of picks 10 and 18 for Shai Bolton is both bold and reasonable, but if Richmond chooses to reject it, the Dockers may need to resist the temptation to overpay.

If Fremantle can secure Bolton within reasonable terms, he could be the player who takes them to the next level. However, if Richmond’s demands escalate beyond their comfort zone, walking away might be the wisest path forward. The Dockers will need to carefully weigh their options as they look to build a list capable of competing for a premiership in the near future.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*