Alex Van Halen Reflects on His Brother Eddie Van Halen’s Remark About Roger Waters in New Memoir

In a recently released memoir, Alex Van Halen, drummer for the legendary rock band Van Halen, opened up about various aspects of his career and personal life, offering readers rare insight into the Van Halen brothers’ musical journey. One of the more intriguing anecdotes centers on a remark made by his late brother, Eddie Van Halen, about Pink Floyd’s co-founder, Roger Waters—a comment that would, years later, prove eerily accurate.

According to Alex, during a discussion about the landscape of rock music in the 1970s, Eddie made a striking observation about Waters. While Pink Floyd was already a towering figure in progressive rock with albums like Dark Side of the Moon and Wish You Were Here, Eddie noted a certain intensity in Waters’ personality. “He’s brilliant,” Eddie said of Waters, “but I think one day, his need for control is going to tear him apart from the rest of the band.”

At the time, Roger Waters was celebrated not only for his songwriting and vision but also for his role as a unifying force in Pink Floyd’s conceptual works. However, as history unfolded, Eddie’s prediction came true. Waters eventually left Pink Floyd in the mid-1980s after a series of creative disputes, particularly during the making of The Wall and The Final Cut, where his dominance over the band became a source of tension. The band’s internal conflicts resulted in a very public and bitter split that shook the rock world.

Alex reflected on his brother’s insight with a sense of awe in the memoir, noting that Eddie had an uncanny ability to read people and their creative dynamics. “He was always dialed in to the energy of the room, whether it was during our sessions or when talking about other bands. I think he saw something in Waters—a kind of drive and vision that, while brilliant, had the potential to isolate him.”

The split within Pink Floyd remains one of rock’s most infamous band breakups, and while both Waters and the remaining members, including David Gilmour and Nick Mason, have continued to create music, the rift has never truly healed. Alex Van Halen’s memoir serves as not only a tribute to his brother’s legacy but also a fascinating glimpse into the shared reverence and rivalry among rock’s greatest figures.

The memoir further highlights Eddie’s love for Pink Floyd’s music, despite his critique of Waters’ strong-willed nature. Both Van Halen and Pink Floyd revolutionized their respective genres—Van Halen with their virtuosic guitar-driven hard rock and Pink Floyd with their expansive, philosophical soundscapes. Eddie’s perspective on Roger Waters underscores the interconnectedness of rock’s major players, even when their paths diverged musically.

In sharing this anecdote, Alex gives readers a sense of Eddie’s deep understanding of the music industry and the personalities that shaped it, revealing another layer of the late guitarist’s genius that went beyond his virtuosic playing.

As fans continue to reflect on the legacy of Eddie Van Halen, Alex’s memoir offers a chance to see the world through his brother’s perceptive eyes, capturing not just the music but the personalities and creative forces that defined an era.