“He is good but can’t be Better than me” Roger Waters, a legendary musician, has acknowledged David Gilmour, but…Read more

Roger Waters, legendary musician and co-founder of Pink Floyd, recently commented on his former bandmate and guitarist, David Gilmour, saying, “He is good but can’t be better than me.” While the remark may seem bold, it speaks to the complicated relationship between two of rock’s most iconic figures. Waters and Gilmour created some of Pink Floyd’s most celebrated music together, yet they often clashed over creative direction, artistic control, and personal differences. Waters’ acknowledgment of Gilmour’s talent is tempered by his conviction in his own contributions, underscoring the pride he takes in his lyrical, conceptual, and musical influence on the band’s legacy.

The tensions between Waters and Gilmour have been widely documented and extend back to the 1970s, when Pink Floyd was at the peak of its success. Waters was instrumental in shaping the band’s direction, especially with concept-driven albums like *The Dark Side of the Moon*, *Wish You Were Here*, and *The Wall*. His themes of social alienation, human struggle, and psychological introspection helped Pink Floyd transcend conventional rock, transforming it into a powerful narrative force. Gilmour, on the other hand, contributed immensely to the band’s sound, with his melodic guitar work, soulful solos, and emotional depth bringing a unique balance to Waters’ intensity.

While Waters often took a leading role in Pink Floyd’s later work, Gilmour’s influence, particularly in shaping the band’s soundscape and vocal identity, was also vital. Gilmour’s guitar solos, such as in “Comfortably Numb” and “Shine On You Crazy Diamond,” remain some of the most recognizable in rock history, enhancing the emotional weight of Waters’ lyrics. This blend of Waters’ lyrical and thematic vision with Gilmour’s musical sensitivity gave Pink Floyd its distinctive edge, making their partnership creatively fruitful even as personal conflicts brewed beneath the surface.

Waters’ remark, though pointed, likely reflects a complex mix of respect, competitiveness, and pride in his own artistic vision. While fans may continue to debate who contributed more to Pink Floyd’s success, it’s clear that both Waters and Gilmour played irreplaceable roles. Their collaborations, even with the underlying tensions, resulted in music that continues to inspire and captivate. Waters’ remark serves as a reminder of the creative sparks that can arise from intense partnerships and the legacy they have built, which remains unparalleled in rock history.