That’s Exactly Why Brock Purdy Drives People Insane

If Saturday night’s divisional round clash between the San Francisco 49ers and Green Bay Packers marked your first encounter with 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy this season, you’re now well-acquainted with how he’s been causing headaches for those trying to assess his skills.

In the critical moments of the 49ers’ decisive drive that secured their victory, Brock Purdy showcased the form that has propelled him into MVP discussions this season. Trailing 21-17 with just over six minutes remaining, Purdy orchestrated a clutch 12-play, 69-yard touchdown march. He connected on six of seven passes, including a crucial third-down conversion to Brandon Aiyuk. Notably, Purdy demonstrated his poise with a strategic nine-yard scramble, setting the stage for Christian McCaffrey’s game-winning touchdown run. This performance mirrored Purdy’s regular-season success, where the second-year QB posted a remarkable 12-4 record, threw for 4,280 yards, notched 31 touchdowns, and limited interceptions to just 11.

Prior to the pivotal final drive, Brock Purdy displayed a contrasting performance, evoking criticism from some quarters this season. Dubbed by skeptics as a system quarterback, Purdy seemed reliant on the talents of Christian McCaffrey, Deebo Samuel, George Kittle, Kyle Shanahan’s play-calling, and the formidable 49ers’ defense. Throughout most of the game, Purdy struggled, tossing interceptable passes that narrowly escaped turnovers. His accuracy wavered, over and underthrowing receivers, presenting a playoff quarterback seemingly out of place. Until the last drive, he found himself outperformed by Jordan Love, who showcased courage and effectiveness in areas where Purdy appeared hesitant and deficient. This performance echoed past struggles, including a four-interception game against the Ravens on Christmas and five interceptions across three consecutive losses in October.

The dual nature of Brock Purdy, oscillating between a resilient, clutch performer and an overwhelmed check-down artist, has become a central topic in televised sports debates. This question persists and will likely do so until the conclusion of the 49ers’ season. Aesthetic considerations contribute to this debate, with Purdy’s performance on Saturday highlighting the contrast. Despite modest statistics in the initial three quarters, the visual impression of how he played lingers in discussions, adding a layer to the ongoing analysis of Purdy’s capabilities.

Brock Purdy displayed a noticeable lack of confidence in his passes throughout the game, seemingly preoccupied with the rainy conditions affecting his grip. He started with a glove, later removing it, and even resorted to wiping his hand on his pant leg mid-drop-back. His demeanor appeared hesitant and tentative when facing pressure in the pocket, often concluding drives with rueful head shakes or frustrated claps after poorly thrown passes. This portrayal is less than ideal for a starting quarterback in a playoff game, especially when juxtaposed with the opposing QB confidently making bare-handed, back-foot completions downfield. Perhaps a slightly altered version of Purdy, taller and delivering passes with more velocity, taking a more assertive approach to evade sacks, might escape the intense scrutiny of his abilities. The distinction between being a subpar quarterback and merely appearing as one is crucial.

The scrutiny surrounding Purdy and the 49ers lies more with those dissecting the team than an inherent issue for the squad. The 49ers don’t solely rely on Purdy; their destiny hinges on the collective contributions of McCaffrey, Aiyuk, Samuels, Kittle, Warner, Greenlaw, and other high-caliber players on the roster. It’s not uncommon for exceptional teams to contend for the Super Bowl despite having an unconventional or occasionally underwhelming quarterback, as demonstrated by Eli Manning’s Giants. As for whether Brock Purdy qualifies as a championship-caliber quarterback.

share your thoughts in the comments.